Nathan Cahoone is a native Rhode Islander, arriving in Newport from Westerly. He plays his college baseball for the Rhode Island College Anchormen, where he appeared in 23 games this season, recording five hits, four RBI, and six runs scored. He also played for the Anchorman during his sophomore year, but saw little action during his first year with the team after transferring from Southern Vermont.

While at Westerly High School, he earned All-State and All-Division honors. He also earned All-Academic honors in both baseball and football.