Even though South Fayette's Jordan Timmons netted two goals and Daniel Pollock contributed one point, South Fayette was held to a tie by Sewickley Academy, 3-3 (OT).

Sewickley Academy was helped by Jack Duggan, who grabbed two goals. Duggan scored the first of his two goals at 15:56 into the first period to make the score 2-1 Sewickley Academy. Duggan's next tally made the score 3-2 Sewickley Academy with 8:23 left in the second period. Willie Paul picked up the assist. Sewickley Academy also got points from Paul, who also finished with one goal and one assist to lead the team in points. Other players who recorded assists for Sewickley Academy were Andrew Beck and Ryan Gex, who each chipped in one.

South Fayette's offense operated below its season average. South Fayette averages 6.2 goals per game. South Fayette kept Sewickley Academy's goalie busy throughout the game, and Cole Luther made 72 saves on 75 shots.

In addition, South Fayette received assists from Jacob Stack, Glenn Manni, John Lipovich, Brandon Poage, and John Trinkala, who contributed one each.

Sewickley Academy incurred four minutes in penalty time with two minors. South Fayette's Kyle Sharp stopped 12 shots out of the 15 that he faced. South Fayette incurred four minutes in penalty time with two minors.