Andrew pitched for the Blazers in 2008 with a 4-0 record, leading the team in saves (5) and was selected to the ACBL All-star team. He is the top closer in Wagner history with 25 saves including a single season record of 13. Andrew signed with the Baltimore Orioles and pitched for two seasons with the Gulf Coast and Bluefield teams.

As a closer, he fanned 34 and walked only 13 in 41 innings with a 3.89 ERA. He is a graduate of North Penn High School, where he served as a pitching coach. His sister,   Julie, is head coach of the Tusculum College softball team.