Luttfring played his first season of college baseball in 2021 at Lake Sumter State College. He appeared in ten games, coming out of the bullpen six times and making four starts. He struck out 15 batters in 16.1 innings on the mound, striking out nearly one hitter per inning. During his prep career at Apopka High, Luttfring was named a Preseason All-American by Perfect Game.