M2 West Chester University's Teddy Smith scored 4:15 into overtime to beat M2 Seton Hall University, 5-4 (OT).

M2 West Chester University forced its penalty killing units to work especially hard during the game, picking up seven minors and one major for 19 minutes in penalty time. M2 West Chester University had been averaging 12.0 minutes in penalties per game. M2 West Chester University's offense was clicking better than usual and put 47 shots on goal during the game, better than the 3.3 shots per game it averages.

M2 West Chester University additionally got points from Daniel Schwartzman, who also racked up one goal and one assist to lead the team in points. Others who scored for M2 West Chester University included Daniel Plinke, Derek Mathews, and Patrick Wilson, who each put in one. More assists for M2 West Chester University came via Drew Fisher and Scott Musser, who contributed one each.

M2 West Chester University was unable to stop M2 Seton Hall University from sending pucks towards the net, and M2 Seton Hall University eventually piled up 36 shots on goal. M2 Seton Hall University found itself short handed often, totaling 40 penalty minutes and allowing eight power plays.

M2 Seton Hall University was led by Jeff Kuper, who had one goal and two assists. Kuper scored on the power play 10:02 into the third period to make the score 3-3. M2 Seton Hall University had gotten the advantage when M2 West Chester University's Justin Roberts was sent off for interference. Bryan Nagy assisted on the tally. M2 Seton Hall University also had goals scored by Pj Carfagno, Charlie Mule, and Rob Harrison, who scored one goal each. In addition, M2 Seton Hall University received assists from Andrew Cameron, Jesse Butler, and Charles Tobias, who each chipped in one.

Sage Wronowski made 32 saves for M2 West Chester University on 36 shots. Zack Peras made 27 saves before being replaced by Jeffrey Hawriluk, who took the otl and made 15 saves. M2 Seton Hall University registered two goals on six power play opportunities.