2019 is Andrews' freshman year at Miami University (NCAA DI, Mid-American Conference). He played high school baseball and football at Bishop Watterson High School in Columbus.

As a senior, Andrews was named second-team All-Ohio and first-team All-District. He was honorable mention All-Ohio as a junior. 

According to Prep Baseball Report, Andrews is an above-average catcher defensively with the ability to hit with gap-to-gap power. 

Andrews should be familiar with playing at VA Memorial Stadium, as Bishop Watterson has made a yearly trek to play at the Home of the Paints for the past several years. He is also familiar with collegiate summer baseball.

As a catcher for the Great Lakes Summer Collegiate League's Galion Graders last summer, Andrews played in 24 games and hit .227 with four doubles, two home runs and ten RBIs as one of the youngest players in the league.