Orlando made 10 appearances for Binghamton as a sophomore, appearing in 10 games and starting one. Averaging just less than a strikeout per inning pitched, the 6-foot-0, 175 pound Bearcat improved on a successful freshman year. In his freshman season, the righty made eight appearances and two starts, including 2.1 innings against Marist where he did not allow an earned run. In his first six appearances at the NCAA level, Orlando recorded at least one strikeout.

As a high school student-athlete, Orlando earned all-conference honors in both baseball as a pitcher and a basketball player. Orlando also dominated the gridiron, as he achieved all-state honors while leading his team in back-to-back semifinal appearances.